(I am so tired. This may not make sense)
I’m sure you’re sick of reading about ECW on Sci Fi by now; I know I kinda am. Still, there’s something that was mentioned that’s been stuck in my head, and I’ve been thinking it over for a day.
During the title belt presentation skit to start the show, Styles said like “RVD was the best wrestler never to win a world title.” Storyline wise, that’s seems correct, and if we take it as so, who does that leave? Who is the best current wrestler to never be world (singles) champion?
This is much more a golf concept than a wrestling one, but it’s been used as a tag line before on screen for Chris Benoit and by fans for Owen Hart and Eddie Guerrero, among others. The increased amount of title changes (and the increased amount of World champions) means there’s less to choose from, but I think it’s still an interesting question – you get to play with the nebulous concept of “merit” and rate their current level of performance to figure out their “current wrestler” level; it’s a perfect unanswerable question (which I usually hate.)
There’s actually a question inside of a question, too:
“Does holding [promotion name here]’s World Title truly make them a World Champion?” Depending on whether the ROH Title is a world title in your mind, Joe and Danielson may be eligible. A cynic may want to make the case that the NWA/TNA and/or SmackDown! titles aren’t/haven’t been world titles for a while, but I wouldn’t go that far. I think those decisions you’ve got to come up on your own.
For simplicities sake, I think you might have to narrow it down to “best wrestler in their region” and assume US. I have no idea who’d it’d be in Japan, and Mexico depends heavily on what titles are World Titles. (I’m thinking either Perro, Chessman, or Bucanero, but I’m afraid I’m missing someone.)
In the US, who would YOU pick as the best current wrestler? It wasn’t really obvious to me at first, but I thought about it for a day, and I think I have an answer. I’ll put it after the link just so you can think about it.